Brazil’s Supreme Court to Reconsider Gambling Ban
Brazil's Supreme Federal Court is moving closer to revisiting the nation's gambling ban after Justice Flávio Dino returned a previously paused case, prompting debates over constitutional alignment and potential consolidated hearings.
Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court (STF) has moved closer to revisiting the nation’s ban on gambling after Justice Flávio Dino handed back a case that he had previously paused for review in August. These legal proceedings focus on whether gambling ought to stay classified as a criminal misdemeanor under Brazilian statutes.
On Thursday, November 12, Dino formally returned the case. The STF has not yet scheduled the upcoming hearing, as that determination lies with court president Justice Edson Fachin.
At the heart of the legal dispute is Article 50 of the 1941 Misdemeanor Act, which outlaws gambling and mandates simple imprisonment ranging from three months to one year, alongside a monetary fine. The magistrates must assess whether this limitation aligns with the provisions of Brazil’s 1988 Constitution.
Judges Weigh Combined Hearings On Gambling Disputes
Back in August, Dino asked for extra time while the court evaluated whether multiple legal challenges concerning betting and gambling should be consolidated into a single hearing. These connected proceedings involve municipal lotteries and alternative ventures within the Brazilian betting sector.
Justice Luiz Fux, who serves as the rapporteur for the challenge against the gambling ban, cast a vote to maintain the current penalties. He also agreed to the potential inclusion of related lawsuits in a joint proceeding following a 90-day window, which provides a chance to draft a more comprehensive opinion.
Meanwhile, Justice Dias Toffoli supported a unified review, highlighting the evolution of the gambling sector since the drafting of the initial laws.
“It is not just about the Misdemeanor Act. It is a new, complex, and difficult world; it is not the world of the 1940s,” he declared.
Initially, Fachin leaned toward holding separate judgments, yet he mentioned he would weigh the perspectives of his fellow justices. During a November 4 debate concerning ADPF 1212, he suggested that a unified strategy might emerge after reviewing points raised during a recent public hearing.
“The Presidency’s stance is toward a separate judgment,” Fachin stated during the session discussing ADPF 1212. “However, I am open, of course, to the considerations of the panel and, given what we have seen here, including some arguments referencing yesterday’s public hearing, perhaps that is the path to eventually follow.”
Municipal Lottery Authority Adds Another Legal Challenge
The possibility of merging the cases drew significant focus during the STF session on November 4. The magistrates listened to oral arguments regarding ADPF 1212, which addresses whether local municipalities possess the authority to set up and run their own lottery programs, encompassing sports lotteries.
This conversation came on the heels of a public hearing addressing the impacts of a provisional measure enacted by President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva on September 25. That specific directive temporarily halted the provision, promotion, and operation of online gaming and sports wagering nationwide. The constitutionality of this measure is likewise facing scrutiny at the STF.
Provisional Measure Extended Into 2027
The National Congress has not yet formed the joint committee tasked with reviewing the measure. In the interim, Senate President Davi Alcolumbre prolonged its effective period by an additional 60 days.
Accounting for the pause in legislative schedules during the parliamentary break, this extension means the measure could remain active through March 2027.
Opting for a consolidated hearing would grant the STF the opportunity to evaluate interrelated issues regarding betting operations, municipal lottery authority, and gambling limits. The high court has yet to verify whether it will pursue this strategy or when the currently deferred case will reappear on its calendar.
“Justice Flávio Dino releases gaming lawsuit for STF analysis”, igamingbrazil.com, November 12, 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the legal basis for the gambling prohibition in Brazil?
The dispute centers on Article 50 of the 1941 Misdemeanor Act, which prohibits gambling and prescribes simple imprisonment of three months to one year, alongside a fine.
Who returned the suspended gambling case to the STF?
Justice Flávio Dino returned the case on Thursday, November 12, after having suspended it for review in August.
Who determines the date for the next STF hearing?
The decision regarding when to hold the next hearing rests with court president Justice Edson Fachin.
What is ADPF 1212 about?
ADPF 1212 concerns whether municipalities can establish and operate their own lottery services, including sports lotteries.
How long has the provisional measure regarding sports betting and online games been extended?
Senate President Davi Alcolumbre extended the provisional measure’s validity by another 60 days, which, taking into account the suspension of legislative deadlines during the parliamentary recess, could keep the measure in force until March 2027.



